Selican News
Follow Up on Estimates: A Simple Plan for Contractors
You walked the job, took the measurements, drove back to the shop and built the estimate. You sent it Tuesday. It is Friday and your phone has not made a sound. Now the second-guessing starts: did the price scare them off, did they hire the other guy, or did your email get buried?
Most owners react one of two ways. Some never follow up because it feels pushy. Others send "just checking in" three times and hope something sticks. Both leave jobs on the table. There is a middle path, and it is mostly a schedule you write once and follow every week.
A case study worth learning from
Valve+Meter Performance Marketing, a marketing agency that works with home services companies, sent a secret shopper to 466 home services companies across the United States. The shopper submitted lead forms, appointment requests, quote estimates and other service inquiries, then tracked every response for five days. A company that never replied within five days counted as not responding at all. The agency published the results around 2018 in its State of Speed to Lead in Home Services report (read the study PDF).
The results show how little follow-up is happening. Only 60 percent of the companies responded within the five-day window. In the report's own words, "two out of five companies completely ignored our request for service." And 85 percent never tried to call back a second time. One company made 8 call attempts over the five days, the most in the study. The shortest gap between a first and second call, by any company, was 4 minutes.
Read those numbers the way an owner should. If most companies stop after one attempt, the homeowner still deciding often hears from nobody. The second and third touch is where jobs are won, and almost nobody shows up for it.
Selican is not affiliated with Valve+Meter, Housecall Pro, the Home Improvement Research Institute, Proposify or 99 Calls, and results depend on the market and the business.
Why homeowners go quiet after a quote
Silence rarely means no. The Home Improvement Research Institute, a nonprofit research group for the home improvement industry, reported in its 2023 research that homeowners who hire a professional contact one to two companies on average, and just over half contact only one (HIRI infographic). If you are the only quote, the decision may still be sitting with a spouse or a savings account.
When homeowners do compare, price is a common trigger. Housecall Pro, a software company for home service pros, surveyed more than 1,100 U.S. homeowners and reported in May 2026 that 68 percent seek additional quotes when pricing comes in higher than expected (read the release). A quiet homeowner may be shopping your number around, not rejecting you. Follow-up keeps your name in the conversation while they shop.
How do you follow up on an estimate without nagging?
1. Promise the follow-up at the walk-through
Before you leave the driveway, say when you will check back: "I'll send the estimate tonight and check in Friday morning." Now your follow-up is a kept promise instead of a sales call. Write the date down so it actually happens.
2. Send the estimate with next steps in writing
Include how to accept, how long the price holds, and when you could start. Proposify, a proposal software company, found in its 2024 State of Proposals report that proposals with automated reminders are "10% more likely to close, but only 7% of sellers use them" (read the report). Proposify's advice to sellers: follow up after one day if the proposal has not been opened. No automation yet? Put a recurring 24-hour reminder on your calendar the moment you hit send.
3. Make touch two useful, not needy
Two days later, send one short message that adds something: the answer to a question they asked, a photo of a similar finished job, or the one detail most bids leave out. The credit for this framing belongs to 99 Calls, whose contractor follow-up guide puts it plainly: "following up isn't inherently pushy," what matters is how you do it. Name the job and the street. Skip "just checking in" entirely.
4. Make your quote easy to compare
When homeowners compare bids, they are often reading documents that each describe the job differently. Make yours the easy one. Put a short list at the top: what is included, what is not, warranty terms, cleanup and timeline. If you offer options, present them as good, better and best with the price differences stated. A homeowner who can compare your quote to the others in one minute has fewer reasons to stall.
5. Close the loop, then stop
Two or three touches is a plan. Ten is a pest. End with one message that leaves the door open: "No rush. If the timing is off this season, I'll be here in the spring." Then move to the next estimate. Some of those quiet quotes come back to life weeks or months later, and the polite, organized company is the one they remember.
The bottom line
The quotes you already wrote are the cheapest jobs you will ever chase. A 48-hour check-in, one or two useful touches and a clean close-out turn quiet estimates into booked work. If you want that sequence to run itself, Selican's AI CRM keeps every quote in a pipeline and sends the follow-ups for you.
Need a hand?
If you try this and want a hand, book a free 15-minute call with one of our qualified specialists. Bring two or three quiet estimates and we will help you map the follow-up for each one.
Sources: Valve+Meter Performance Marketing, "The State of Speed to Lead in Home Services"; Housecall Pro, "Housecall Pro releases 2026 home spending report: Key findings"; Home Improvement Research Institute, "How Homeowners are Working with Professionals" (2023 infographic); Proposify, "State of Proposals 2024"; 99 Calls, "Estimate Sent, No Response? Here's How Contractors Should Follow Up" by Dipa Gandhi.